View 12 Highland Avenue Monticello, NY MLS# 962137
    Save 12 Highland Avenue Monticello, NY MLS# 962137
    1 of 14
    $240,000
    3

    Beds

    1.0

    Baths

    1,538

    Sq.Ft.

    12 Highland Avenue

    Monticello, NY

    Courtesy of MS REALTY GROUP USA, INC
    View 458 Broadway Monticello, NY MLS# 959022
      Save 458 Broadway Monticello, NY MLS# 959022
      1 of 13
      $200,000
      5,940

      Sq.Ft.

      458 Broadway

      Monticello, NY

      Courtesy of CURASI REALTY, INC.
      View 751 Sackett Lake Road Monticello, NY MLS# 953350
        Save 751 Sackett Lake Road Monticello, NY MLS# 953350
        1 of 2
        $249,900
        Studio

        Beds

        0.0

        Baths

        473,933

        Sq.Ft.

        751 Sackett Lake Road

        Monticello, NY

        Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY
        The time to sell is now! THE TIME TO SELL IS NOW!
        View 296 Southwoods Drive Monticello, NY MLS# 951088
          Save 296 Southwoods Drive Monticello, NY MLS# 951088
          1 of 8
          $225,000
          3

          Beds

          1.1

          Baths

          1,100

          Sq.Ft.

          296 Southwoods Drive

          Monticello, NY

          Courtesy of R J KATZ REALTY
          View 31 Cold Spring Road Monticello, NY MLS# 944734
            Save 31 Cold Spring Road Monticello, NY MLS# 944734
            1 of 11
            $249,000
            3

            Beds

            1.1

            Baths

            1,000

            Sq.Ft.

            31 Cold Spring Road

            Monticello, NY

            Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS HUDSON VALLEY
            View 565 Cold Spring Road Monticello, NY MLS# 928117
              Save 565 Cold Spring Road Monticello, NY MLS# 928117
              1 of 16
              $216,500
              2

              Beds

              1.0

              Baths

              1,008

              Sq.Ft.

              565 Cold Spring Road

              Monticello, NY

              Courtesy of RESORT REALTY
              View Crystal St Crystal Street Monticello, NY MLS# 927510
                Save Crystal St Crystal Street Monticello, NY MLS# 927510
                1 of 1
                $235,000
                Studio

                Beds

                0.0

                Baths

                26,208

                Sq.Ft.

                Crystal St Crystal Street

                Monticello, NY

                Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS HUDSON VALLEY
                View Highland Avenue Monticello, NY MLS# 921603
                  Save Highland Avenue Monticello, NY MLS# 921603
                  1 of 17
                  $265,000
                  Studio

                  Beds

                  0.0

                  Baths

                  213,444

                  Sq.Ft.

                  Highland Avenue

                  Monticello, NY

                  Courtesy of CURASI REALTY, INC.
                  View 6 Leonardo Road Monticello, NY MLS# 897054
                    Save 6 Leonardo Road Monticello, NY MLS# 897054
                    1 of 36
                    $249,999
                    3

                    Beds

                    1.0

                    Baths

                    1,027

                    Sq.Ft.

                    6 Leonardo Road

                    Monticello, NY

                    Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY
                    View 3560 State Route 42 Monticello, NY MLS# 900533
                      Save 3560 State Route 42 Monticello, NY MLS# 900533
                      1 of 29
                      $215,000
                      3

                      Beds

                      2.0

                      Baths

                      1,514

                      Sq.Ft.

                      3560 State Route 42

                      Monticello, NY

                      Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS HUDSON VALLEY
                      View 89 Cold Spring Road Monticello, NY MLS# 837895
                        Save 89 Cold Spring Road Monticello, NY MLS# 837895
                        1 of 3
                        $249,999
                        4

                        Beds

                        1.0

                        Baths

                        1,256

                        Sq.Ft.

                        89 Cold Spring Road

                        Monticello, NY

                        Courtesy of RODEO REALTY INC

                        About Monticello

                        Listings in Monticello, NY

                        120

                        Estimated median home price

                        $432,450
                        Monticello NY Homes for Sale & Properties

                        Weichert Realtors is one of the nation's leading providers of Monticello, New York real estate for sale and home ownership services. Contact Weichert today to buy or sell real estate in Monticello, NY.

                        Homes for Sale by Price in Monticello, NY

                        PriceCount
                        $0 - 100K12
                        $100K - 200K7
                        $200K - 300K21
                        $300K - 400K18
                        $400K - 500K10
                        $500K - 600K7
                        $600K - 700K7
                        $700K - 800K7
                        $800K - 900K3
                        $900K - 1M5
                        $1M - Max23

                        Homes for Sale by Type in Monticello, NY

                        Property TypeCount
                        Single Family48
                        Townhouse0
                        Condo0
                        Commercial25
                        Rental36
                        Lots and Land36
                        Condo/Town/CoOp0
                        CoOp0
                        Multi Family8
                        Mobile Home3
                        Farms0

                        (Data as of 3/24/2026)

                        Find Properties in Monticello, NY

                        Monticello, NY Information

                        Find Properties by Zip

                        Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

                        The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of OneKey® MLS.

                        The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use.

                        Information Copyright 2021, OneKey® MLS. All Rights Reserved.