View 250 Old Montauk Highway Montauk, NY MLS# 1021256
  • Virtual Tour
Save 250 Old Montauk Highway Montauk, NY MLS# 1021256
1 of 12
$22,500,000
4

Beds

4.2

Baths

7,100

Sq.Ft.

250 Old Montauk Highway

Montauk, NY

Courtesy of NYONLINEREALTY.COM
View 408 Old Montauk Montauk, NY MLS# L3586218
    Save 408 Old Montauk Montauk, NY MLS# L3586218
    1 of 22
    $18,000,000
    3

    Beds

    4.1

    Baths

    4,027

    Sq.Ft.

    408 Old Montauk

    Montauk, NY

    Courtesy of NYONLINEREALTY.COM
    View 18 Homeward Lane Montauk, NY MLS# 954433
      Save 18 Homeward Lane Montauk, NY MLS# 954433
      1 of 1
      $9,900,000
      0.0

      Baths

      34,848

      Sq.Ft.

      18 Homeward Lane

      Montauk, NY

      Courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER AMERICAN HOMES
      The time to sell is now! THE TIME TO SELL IS NOW!
      View 809 & 813 Montauk Highway Montauk, NY MLS# 1013518
        Save 809 & 813 Montauk Highway Montauk, NY MLS# 1013518
        1 of 48
        $6,000,000
        5,000

        Sq.Ft.

        809 & 813 Montauk Highway

        Montauk, NY

        Courtesy of NEST SEEKERS INTERNATIONAL LLC
        View 29 Monroe Drive Montauk, NY MLS# 1034737
          Save 29 Monroe Drive Montauk, NY MLS# 1034737
          1 of 26
          OPEN HOUSE: Saturday 10/10 10:00 AM - 12:00 PM
          $5,695,000
          6

          Beds

          5.2

          Baths

          4,500

          Sq.Ft.

          29 Monroe Drive

          Montauk, NY

          Courtesy of DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE
          View 25 S Duncan Drive Montauk, NY MLS# 1037158
            Save 25 S Duncan Drive Montauk, NY MLS# 1037158
            1 of 25
            $5,250,000
            6

            Beds

            5.1

            Baths

            5,206

            Sq.Ft.

            25 S Duncan Drive

            Montauk, NY

            Courtesy of ISLAND POLO REALTY INC
            View 19 Elm Lane Montauk, NY MLS# 959062
              Save 19 Elm Lane Montauk, NY MLS# 959062
              1 of 27
              $4,895,000
              6

              Beds

              4.1

              Baths

              5,155

              Sq.Ft.

              19 Elm Lane

              Montauk, NY

              Courtesy of DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE
              View 15 Edgemere Street Montauk, NY MLS# 982906
                Save 15 Edgemere Street Montauk, NY MLS# 982906
                1 of 50
                $4,199,000
                4

                Beds

                4.0

                Baths

                2,400

                Sq.Ft.

                15 Edgemere Street

                Montauk, NY

                Courtesy of ERIC G RAMSAY JR ASSOC LLC
                View 18 Tara Road Montauk, NY MLS# 1047183
                • Virtual Tour
                Save 18 Tara Road Montauk, NY MLS# 1047183
                1 of 20
                $3,799,000
                4

                Beds

                3.0

                Baths

                3,500

                Sq.Ft.

                18 Tara Road

                Montauk, NY

                Courtesy of GREAT ESTATES NEW YORK LLC
                View 130 Laurel Drive Montauk, NY MLS# 1049371
                  Save 130 Laurel Drive Montauk, NY MLS# 1049371
                  1 of 45
                  $3,195,000
                  4

                  Beds

                  3.0

                  Baths

                  2,480

                  Sq.Ft.

                  130 Laurel Drive

                  Montauk, NY

                  Courtesy of BROWN HARRIS STEVENS HAMPTONS
                  View 100 Deforest Road 25 Montauk, NY MLS# 927588
                    Save 100 Deforest Road 25 Montauk, NY MLS# 927588
                    1 of 21
                    $2,995,000
                    2

                    Beds

                    1.0

                    Baths

                    700

                    Sq.Ft.

                    100 Deforest Road 25

                    Montauk, NY

                    Courtesy of DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE
                    View 45 Ditch Plains Road Montauk, NY MLS# 952737
                      Save 45 Ditch Plains Road Montauk, NY MLS# 952737
                      1 of 19
                      $2,995,000
                      3

                      Beds

                      3.0

                      Baths

                      1,500

                      Sq.Ft.

                      45 Ditch Plains Road

                      Montauk, NY

                      Courtesy of DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE
                      View 45 S Elmwood Avenue Montauk, NY MLS# 1056133
                      • Recently Listed
                      Save 45 S Elmwood Avenue Montauk, NY MLS# 1056133
                      1 of 4
                      $2,995,000
                      2,800

                      Sq.Ft.

                      45 S Elmwood Avenue

                      Montauk, NY

                      Courtesy of HEDGESTONE COMMERCIAL RLTY LLC
                      View 113 Duryea Avenue Montauk, NY MLS# 1021724
                        Save 113 Duryea Avenue Montauk, NY MLS# 1021724
                        1 of 29
                        $2,975,000
                        6

                        Beds

                        3.0

                        Baths

                        2,312

                        Sq.Ft.

                        113 Duryea Avenue

                        Montauk, NY

                        Courtesy of DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE
                        View 84 N Surfside Avenue Montauk, NY MLS# 1041710
                          Save 84 N Surfside Avenue Montauk, NY MLS# 1041710
                          1 of 28
                          $2,795,000
                          4

                          Beds

                          2.0

                          Baths

                          2,076

                          Sq.Ft.

                          84 N Surfside Avenue

                          Montauk, NY

                          Courtesy of DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE
                          View 166 Greenwich Street Montauk, NY MLS# 1046325
                            Save 166 Greenwich Street Montauk, NY MLS# 1046325
                            1 of 28
                            $2,595,000
                            3

                            Beds

                            2.1

                            Baths

                            1,976

                            Sq.Ft.

                            166 Greenwich Street

                            Montauk, NY

                            Courtesy of BROWN HARRIS STEVENS HAMPTONS
                            View 15 Elm Lane Montauk, NY MLS# 1036630
                              Save 15 Elm Lane Montauk, NY MLS# 1036630
                              1 of 6
                              OPEN HOUSE: Saturday 10/10 1:00 PM - 2:30 PM
                              $2,300,000
                              2

                              Beds

                              2.0

                              Baths

                              1,431

                              Sq.Ft.

                              15 Elm Lane

                              Montauk, NY

                              Courtesy of BROWN HARRIS STEVENS HAMPTONS
                              View 14 Hoover Court Montauk, NY MLS# 1032010
                                Save 14 Hoover Court Montauk, NY MLS# 1032010
                                1 of 11
                                $1,999,999
                                3

                                Beds

                                2.0

                                Baths

                                1,500

                                Sq.Ft.

                                14 Hoover Court

                                Montauk, NY

                                Courtesy of DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE
                                View 89 S Elroy Drive Montauk, NY MLS# 1015693
                                  Save 89 S Elroy Drive Montauk, NY MLS# 1015693
                                  1 of 12
                                  $1,500,000
                                  3

                                  Beds

                                  1.1

                                  Baths

                                  810

                                  Sq.Ft.

                                  89 S Elroy Drive

                                  Montauk, NY

                                  Courtesy of DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE
                                  View 33 N Fairfax Road Montauk, NY MLS# 1035713
                                    Save 33 N Fairfax Road Montauk, NY MLS# 1035713
                                    1 of 3
                                    $1,500,000
                                    0.0

                                    Baths

                                    34,412

                                    Sq.Ft.

                                    33 N Fairfax Road

                                    Montauk, NY

                                    Courtesy of DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE

                                    About Montauk

                                    Beautiful Montauk Long Island, NY. Located at the the end of Long Island is a town of wealth, affluence, and natural Beauty. From the clean beach shores to the town business district where you can find anything and everything, Montauk has everything you could ever need. Only 19.8 square miles total, this section of East Hampton is truly Long Island's gem.

                                    Listings in Montauk, NY

                                    28

                                    Estimated median home price

                                    $2,885,000
                                    Montauk NY Homes for Sale & Properties

                                    Weichert Realtors is one of the nation's leading providers of Montauk, New York real estate for sale and home ownership services. Contact Weichert today to buy or sell real estate in Montauk, NY.

                                    Homes for Sale by Price in Montauk, NY

                                    PriceCount
                                    $0 - 100K0
                                    $100K - 200K0
                                    $200K - 300K0
                                    $300K - 400K1
                                    $400K - 500K5
                                    $500K - 600K0
                                    $600K - 700K0
                                    $700K - 800K0
                                    $800K - 900K1
                                    $900K - 1M1
                                    $1M - Max20

                                    Homes for Sale by Type in Montauk, NY

                                    Property TypeCount
                                    Single Family15
                                    Townhouse0
                                    Condo3
                                    Commercial2
                                    Rental8
                                    Lots and Land2
                                    Condo/Town/CoOp0
                                    CoOp6
                                    Multi Family0
                                    Mobile Home0
                                    Farms0

                                    (Data as of 10/3/2026)

                                    Browse Neighborhoods

                                    Find Properties in Montauk, NY

                                    Montauk, NY Information

                                    Find Properties by Zip

                                    Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

                                    The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of OneKey® MLS.

                                    The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use.

                                    Information Copyright 2021, OneKey® MLS. All Rights Reserved.