191 E Colliers Mill Road Plumsted, NJ $ 1,300,000
191 E Colliers Mill Road
$ 1,300,000
Recently Listed
Share Save

191 E Colliers Mill Road

Plumsted, NJ, 08533
$ 1,300,000
Bedrooms4 Baths3.1 Sq 3,012

Monthly Estimate*

$ 8,979

191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 1
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 2
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 3
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 4
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 5
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 6
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 7
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 8
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 9
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 10
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 11
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 12
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 13
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 14
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 15
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 16
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 17
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 18
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 19
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 20
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 21
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 22
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 23
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 24
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 25
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 26
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 27
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 28
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 29
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 30
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 31
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 32
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 33
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 34
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 35
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 36
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 37
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 38
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 39
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 40
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 41
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 42
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 43
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 44
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 45
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 46
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 47
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 48
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 49
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 50
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 51
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 52
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 53
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 54
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 55
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 56
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 57
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 58
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 59
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 60
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 61
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 62
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 63
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 64
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 65
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 66
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 67
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 68
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 69
191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ 08533 - Image 70

Single Family Home for sale in Plumsted, NJ

for $1,300,000 with 4 bedrooms and 3 full baths, 1 half bath. This 3,012 square foot home was built in 2003 on a lot size of 4.08.

Set on more than 4 private acres in Plumsted Township, this beautifully updated 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Colonial offers a rare blend of refined comfort and peaceful country living, with room to live, play, and dream. Your welcome begins on the rocking-chair front porch, the kind of place made for slow mornings and quiet evenings. Step through the custom entryway into an open, light-filled floor plan where every space feels connected and inviting. At the heart of the home, the custom kitchen is both stylish and warm, with white custom cabinetry, classic farm sink, stainless appliances and a breakfast bar for easy conversation over coffee. On cool nights, gather around the stone wood-burning fireplace and let the glow of a real fire set the mood. The beautifully renovated 672 sq.ft. bonus room is a true retreat, finished with radiant heated floors and air conditioning so it feels just right in every season. Whether you picture a media room, studio, or private home office, it adapts gracefully to your lifestyle. A finished basement room adds even more flexible space, and a mudroom/laundry room with outside access keeps everyday life effortlessly organized. Every important update has been thoughtfully handled, so you can simply move in and enjoy. The home features a brand-new roof with 30-year shingles, new 5-Star energy-rated windows and siding (2026), a new hot water heater, and 2-zone heat and A/C with one condenser just two years old. Slide open the doors to your own backyard escape. The expansive deck overlooks a sparkling saltwater pool, an idyllic setting for summer entertaining, sunset dinners, and long, lazy weekends. Beyond, the grounds unfold with a sweeping yard, a privacy-fenced area (formerly a dog run), several fenced areas for small animals, and a 30x50 pole barn with four stalls, ready for horses, hobbies, or your next big idea. With Colliers Mill Recreation Area just down the road, scenic trails and open space are always close at hand. Elegant, comfortable, and surrounded by natural beauty, this is a home where every day feels like a getaway. Schedule your private tour and experience it for yourself.

See more

Single Family Active

Price

$ 1,300,000

Bedrooms

4

Full Bath

3

Half Bath

1

Property Type

Single Family

Taxes

$ 15,648

Style

Detached, Colonial

Lot Size

4.08

Year Built

2003

Town/City

Plumsted

County/Region

Ocean

MLS | Web ID

22635271

Features
General
Sewer Septic Tank
Heating Radiant Oil Above Ground Forced Air Baseboard
Cooling Electric Central Air
Garage Spaces 2
Architectural Style Detached Colonial
Stories Count 2
Property Subtype Single Family Residence
County Ocean
Property Type Residential
HOA false
Attached Garage false
Subdivision Name None
Garage Y/N true
Total Rooms 11
Full Baths 3
Status Active
Directions From intersection of Rt 537 & Rt 539 South on Rt 539 to Left on E Colliers Mills to property on left.
City Plumsted
MLS Area Colliers Mills
Middle/Junior High School New Egypt
MLS Area Minor Plumsted (PLU)
Standard Status Active
Year Built 2003
Tax Year 2025
New Construction false
Tax Annual Amount 15648
Tax Assessed Value 872400
Other Structures Outbuilding Barn(s) Shed(s)
Zoning Description Residential
Patio/Porch Features Deck Porch - Covered
High School New Egypt
Lot Size Square Feet 177724.8
Lot Size Units Acres
Exclusions Personal Property
Roof Sloping Shingle
Pool Features Fenced In Ground Salt Water Vinyl
Topography Level
See more
Interior
Basement Ceilings - High Full Partially Finished
Basement (Y/N) true
Air Conditioning Y/N true
Heating Y/N true
Half Baths 1
Total Bedrooms 4
Total Baths 4
Total Fireplaces 1
Interior Amenities Bonus Room Dec Molding
Flooring Vinyl Plank Other
Main Level Bathrooms 1
Heating-Baseboard true
Heating-Forced Air true
Fireplace Y/N true
Window Features Insulated Windows
Heating-Radiant true
See more
Exterior
Parking Features Paved Driveway Off Street Oversized Workshop in Garage
Water Source Well
Waterfront Y/N false
Lot Features Back to Woods Fenced Area
Inclusions Washer Dishwasher Dryer Microwave Refrigerator Gas Cooking
Lot Size Area 4.08
Building Area Total 3012
Lot Size Acres 4.08
Exterior Amenities Swimming
Fencing Fence
See more
Internal Only
Street Number 1 191
See more
* Excluded Features
List By
Beth Kimmick

Listing Agent

Era Central Realty Group

Broker

bkimmick@eracentral.com

Email

Affordability Calculator

$10,283
Per Month
87%
13%
0%
Monthly Principal & Interest
$8,979
Monthly Property Taxes
$1,304
Monthly Home Insurance
--
Default based on a 30-year fixed rate of 7.375% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA or jumbo loans.
Learn more about how to save

Discover how much house you can afford

Your dream home may be within reach.

Learn More about how to save

The time to sell is now
THE TIME TO SELL IS NOW! What's my home worth?
Nearby
1828054 Elementary School
1828226 Middle School
New Egypt High School High School
Pricing History
DatePricePrice ChangeDescription
11/7/2026$1,300,000 Listed Price

Map


See all

191 E Colliers Mill Road, Plumsted, NJ, 08533 is a Single Family Home for sale at $1,300,000 with 3,012 sqft and a lot size of 4.08. 191 E Colliers Mill Road has 4 bedrooms, 3.1 baths, and was built in 2003. The property's zip code is 08533 which is in Plumsted, NJ