5436 Hamilton Point

Quintessential Honeoye Lake Cottage – Level Beach, Sunset Views & Ultimate Privacy. Welcome to true Finger Lakes living at 5436 Hamilton Point! Tucked away at the end of a quiet private road with no through traffic, this year-round 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath lakefront cottage offers peace, privacy, and incredible short-term rental potential on Honeoye Lake. The heart of the home features a light-filled kitchen with vaulted ceilings, skylights, and exposed wooden beams, along with a warm propane freestanding stove. In the living room, sliding doors open directly onto the deck overlooking the water—perfect for seamless indoor-outdoor entertaining. Downstairs convenience continues with first-floor laundry, while the upper-level primary bedroom features vaulted ceilings and a private balcony with front-row seats to spectacular Finger Lakes sunsets. Outside, enjoy versatile outdoor living with both front and back decks. A level shale beach makes water access effortless for swimming, kayaking, or boating. The property also includes a detached 2-car garage and a storage shed to keep all your water toys and gear secure. Located just minutes from local breweries, dining, parks, and shopping, you’re also perfectly positioned for easy trips to nearby Naples, Canandaigua, and Bristol Mountain. Whether you're seeking a permanent waterfront retreat, a classic vacation escape, or an income-generating investment, this Honeoye gem is ready for its next chapter.