370 Starlight Road
Monticello, NY, 12701 $ 424,900
Bedrooms2 Baths1.1 Sq 1,080 Monthly Estimate*
$ 2,683
for $424,900 with 2 bedrooms and 1 full bath, 1 half bath. This 1,080 square foot home was built in 1929 on a lot size of 2.
There’s something special about a home that has stood the test of time. Welcome to 370 Starlight Rd. Once a neighborhood schoolhouse, this property carries a sense of history you can feel the moment you arrive. Set on two beautifully maintained acres, the setting is quiet, open, and peaceful. It’s the kind of place where mornings feel slower and evenings stretch a little longer. Inside, the home blends old and new in a way that feels natural. Original woodwork and hardwood floors tell the story of its past, while a thoughtfully updated kitchen with stainless steel appliances and a renovated bathroom bring comfort to everyday living. The main living space is warm and inviting, centered around an electric fireplace that makes it easy to picture yourself settling in. Behind the charm, the important updates are already done. Electrical improvements, a newer heating system, and a roof that is only 8 years old offer confidence moving forward. Step outside and the lifestyle opens up. Expansive decks create space to gather, entertain, or simply take in the surroundings. The circular driveway adds ease, while the open land gives you room to use the property in a way that fits your life. What truly sets this property apart is what it can become. With two acres and the right approvals, there is real potential to explore subdivision or the addition of another home. Whether you’re thinking long term investment, creating a compound, or simply holding land for the future, this is a property that offers more than just today. Directly across the street, access to Swinging Bridge Reservoir adds another layer to the experience. A motorboat lake with a marina, it brings recreation and lifestyle right to your doorstep. You are also just minutes from some of the area’s most loved destinations, including The Arnold House for dining, Walnut Mountain Park for trails and views, and Bethel Woods, Resorts World, The Kartrite, and Holiday Mountain. This is more than a home. It’s a piece of history, a place to slow down, and an opportunity to create something meaningful for years to come. Come experience it for yourself.
See more
Open House
7/2/2026 5:00 PM - 7:00 PM
370 Starlight Road Monticello, NY
* Some states or local ordinances may prohibit Open Houses at this time, please confirm with your Weichert agent or local rep to confirm
FeaturesInteriorInterior Amenities First Floor Bedroom First Floor Full Bath Breakfast Bar Built-in Features Ceiling Fan(s) Eat-in Kitchen
Basement Full
Flooring Wood
Basement Features Full
Basement (Y/N) Y
Half Baths 1
Total Bedrooms 2
Total Baths 2
See more
GeneralSewer Septic Tank
Heating Hot Water Oil
Cooling Wall/Window Unit(s)
Utilities Electricity Connected
Appliances Dishwasher Dryer Gas Range Microwave Refrigerator Washer
Patio/Porch Features Deck Porch Wrap Around
Architectural Style Ranch Traditional
Construction Materials Frame Vinyl Siding
Year Built 1929
View Lake Water
Property Subtype Single Family Residence
Tax Year 2025
Parcel Number 4689-041-0-0001-013-000
County Sullivan County
Property Type Residential
HOA N
Garage Y/N N
Total Rooms 5
Full Baths 1
High School Monticello High School
City Thompson
Senior Community Y/N N
High School District Monticello
Carport Y/N N
Elementary School Kenneth L Rutherford School
Property Attached Y/N N
Tax Annual Amount 4933.19
Middle/Junior High School Robert J Kaiser Middle School
Building Area Units Square Feet
Standard Status Active
Middle/Junior School District Monticello
Elementary School District Monticello
Tax Assessed Value 60300
See more
ExteriorParking Features Driveway Driveway
Water Source Well
Waterfront Y/N N
See more
* Excluded FeaturesList ByIsaiah LopezListing Agent
Kw Hudson Valley UnitedBroker
Affordability Calculator
- Monthly Principal & Interest
- $2,683
- Monthly Property Taxes
- $411
- Monthly Home Insurance
- --
Default based on a 30-year fixed rate of 6.49% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA or jumbo loans.
Learn more about how to save NearbySingle family listings in Monticello, NY
Average List Price $573,642
Percent of Sale Price 35%
About Monticello, NY 11,220 Population
0% Since 2002
$ 36,080 Median Income
38.43 Median Age
26% Households with Children
Trends Information provided by ATTOM Data Solutions.
4100353 Elementary School
4100531 Middle School
Monticello High School High School
Pricing History| Date | Price | Price Change | Description |
|---|
| 6/23/2026 | $424,900 | -5.56% | Price Down |
| 5/15/2026 | $449,900 | | Listed Price |