Back to search
2386 Route 5 Sheridan, NY $ 849,900
Share Save
$ 849,900 Get more info
2386 Route 5
$ 849,900
Back to search
Share Save

2386 Route 5

Sheridan, NY, 14136
$ 849,900
Bedrooms5 Baths3.1 Sq 4,192

Monthly Estimate*

$ 5,233

2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 1
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 2
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 3
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 4
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 5
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 6
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 7
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 8
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 9
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 10
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 11
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 12
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 13
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 14
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 15
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 16
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 17
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 18
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 19
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 20
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 21
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 22
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 23
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 24
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 25
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 26
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 27
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 28
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 29
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 30
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 31
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 32
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 33
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 34
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 35
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 36
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 37
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 38
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 39
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 40
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 41
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 42
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 43
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 44
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 45
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 46
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 47
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 48
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 49
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136 - Image 50

Single Family Home for sale in Sheridan, NY

for $849,900 with 5 bedrooms and 3 full baths, 1 half bath. This 4,192 square foot home was built in 1991 on a lot size of 2.4.

Welcome to this custom built 5bd/3.5 bath home on Eagle Bay. As you enter the 2 story foyer a custom floating staircases, sitting area and formal living room greet you. Step up to your right and be prepared for the spectacular open concept design featuring cathedral ceilings and a wall of windows. The kitchen features custom Amish cabinets, quartz countertops, and flows seamlessly into the formal dining room, breakfast bar, great room with woodburning fireplace and a second story catwalk. Just off the dining room you will also find a half bath and the primary suite complete with sitting area, walk-in closet, built in wardrobe and full bath. On the opposite side of the home you will find an additional first floor bedroom with sliding door to patio, a full bath and laundry room. The second floor features 3 bedrooms, a full bath & a second floor covered balcony that overlooks the inground pool and lush floral garden. Updates include roof (2025) and several windows (2026). With over 200' of unobstructed Lake Erie views, this property is a true gem.

See more
Single Family Active

Price

$ 849,900

Bedrooms

5

Full Bath

3

Half Bath

1

Property Type

Single Family

Taxes

$ 10,792

Style

Mediterranean,TwoStory

Lot Size

2.4

Year Built

1991

Town/City

Sheridan

County/Region

Chautauqua

MLS | Web ID

B1679089
Features
Interior
Interior Amenities BreakfastBar CeilingFans CathedralCeilings SeparateFormalDiningRoom EntranceFoyer SeparateFormalLivingRoom GreatRoom KitchenIsland Pantry PullDownAtticStairs SlidingGlassDoors WindowTreatments Bedroo
Basement Partial
Flooring Carpet CeramicTile Hardwood Tile Varies
Total Fireplaces 1
Total Stories 2
Basement (Y/N) Yes
Heating Y/N Yes
Window Features Drapes
Fireplace Y/N Yes
Half Baths 1
Laundry Features AccessibleUtilitiesOrLaundry MainLevel
Total Bedrooms 5
Main Level Bedrooms 2
Main Level Bathrooms 3
Total Baths 4
See more
General
Sewer SepticTank
Heating Gas Zoned Baseboard
Cooling Zoned
Utilities CableAvailable ElectricityConnected HighSpeedInternetAvailable WaterConnected
Possession CloseOfEscrow
Roof Metal
Appliances BuiltInRange BuiltInOven DoubleOven Dryer Dishwasher ElectricCooktop ExhaustFan GasWaterHeater Microwave Refrigerator RangeHood Washer
Garage Spaces 2.5
Patio/Porch Features Balcony Covered Open Patio Porch
Architectural Style Mediterranean TwoStory
Pool Features InGround
Construction Materials Brick Stucco CopperPlumbing
School District Silver Creek
Year Built 1991
Electric CircuitBreakers
View Water
Stories Count 2
Township Not Applicable
Levels Two
Property Subtype SingleFamilyResidence
Waterfront Features Lake Other SeeRemarks
Accessibility AccessibleBedroom Other
County Chautauqua
Property Type Residential
Association Amenities None
Attached Garage Yes
Garage Y/N Yes
Other Structures Other
Total Rooms 15
Full Baths 3
Status Active
Directions I-90 to exit 58 towards Silver Creek. US-20 to Village of Silver Creek then proceed to Route 5. Property is on the right hand side. Address AKA 2386 Lake Ave Silver Creek NY 14136
City Sheridan
Body of Water Lake Erie Eagle Bay
Senior Community Y/N No
High School District Silver Creek
Number Of Units Total 0
MLS Area Sheridan-066400
Lot Size Units Acres
Year Built Details Existing
Tax Annual Amount 10792.0
Property Condition Resale
Standard Status Active
Middle/Junior School District Silver Creek
Elementary School District Silver Creek
Tax Assessed Value 228100
TaxOtherAnnualAssessmentAmount 0.0
Tax Lot 1
See more
Exterior
Exterior Amenities BlacktopDriveway Balcony ConcreteDriveway Pool Patio PrivateYard SeeRemarks
Parking Features Attached Electricity Garage Other
Lot Features IrregularLot Secluded
Water Source Connected Public
Lot Size Area 2.4
Foundation Details Poured
Building Area Total 4192.0
Lot Dimensions 185X512
Lot Size Acres 2.4
Frontage Length 229
Waterfront Y/N Yes
Door Features SlidingDoors
Road Frontage Type MainThoroughfare
See more
Internal Only
Street Number 1 2386
See more
* Excluded Features
List By
Hunt Real Estate Corporation

Broker

(716) 474-5766

Phone

Affordability Calculator

$6,132
Per Month
85%
15%
0%
Monthly Principal & Interest
$5,233
Monthly Property Taxes
$899
Monthly Home Insurance
--
Default based on a 30-year fixed rate of 6.25% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA or jumbo loans.
Learn more about how to save

Discover how much house you can afford

Your dream home may be within reach.

Learn More about how to save

The time to sell is now
THE TIME TO SELL IS NOW! What's my home worth?
Nearby
3040594 Elementary School
3041094 Middle School
Unknown High School High School
Pricing History
DatePricePrice ChangeDescription
5/6/2026$849,900 Listed Price

Map

More homes like this one

homes for you

See all
See all

2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY, 14136 is a Single Family Home for sale at $849,900 with 4,192 sqft and a lot size of 2.4. 2386 Route 5 has 5 bedrooms, 3.1 baths, and was built in 1991. The property's zip code is 14136 which is in Sheridan, NY

Get more info