3969 Route 394
Mayville, NY, 14757 $ 389,500
Bedrooms4 Baths2.1 Sq 2,224 Monthly Estimate*
$ 2,398
for $389,500 with 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths, 1 half bath. This 2,224 square foot home was built in 1858 on a lot size of 0.3564.
Discover a truly one-of-a-kind home where history, character, and modern comfort come together. Thoughtfully transformed from a former church, this inviting 4-Bedroom, 2.5-Bath residence offers distinctive architectural details, generous living spaces, and a versatile loft ideal for a hangout area, office, or year-round retreat. From the moment you enter, you'll be greeted by soaring ceilings, abundant natural light, and preserved architectural elements, including several decorative church-style windows that beautifully reflect the property's rich heritage. The expansive great room seamlessly combines the living, dining, and kitchen areas into one open and welcoming space. Upstairs, the loft adds even more versatility, providing the perfect setting for a reading nook, gaming space, or home office. Please note, approximately 300 square feet in this area is in addition to the approximately 2,300 square feet listed. Originally built in 1858 and decommissioned after 165 years, this former church has been carefully rebuilt and updated. Significant improvements include reinforced floor joists, new flooring, new heating and electrical systems, a new well, and soon new sewer connection. Additional updates include all-new siding, insulation, and 10 new windows. The home features a custom kitchen with stainless steel appliances, a large island, and solid surface countertops. The 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, and ample closet space throughout were thoughtfully created from the former classrooms. Located at the attractive rear entrance, the home features a new laundry area and mechanical closet, with plenty of space for storage. There is plenty of room for parking and relaxing rear sitting areas. Located just 2 miles from CHQ Institution, close to the Lake, and near popular snowmobile trail systems, this property offers the perfect blend of historic charm, modern comfort, and access to year-round recreation—from arts and culture to boating, fishing, and winter sports. Offering a rare blend of historic character and modern comfort this one-of-a-kind property is ideal as either a full-time home or a special retreat to enjoy throughout the year.
See more
Single Family ActiveContemporary,HistoricAntique,Transitional
FeaturesInteriorInterior Amenities CathedralCeilings Den EntranceFoyer GreatRoom KitchenIsland KitchenFamilyRoomCombo LivingDiningRoom Other Pantry PartiallyFurnished SeeRemarks SolidSurfaceCounters BedroomOnMainLevel Loft MainLevelPr
Basement CrawlSpace
Flooring Hardwood LuxuryVinyl Tile Varies
Furnished Y/N Partially
Total Fireplaces 0
Total Stories 1
Heating Y/N Yes
Fireplace Y/N No
Half Baths 1
Laundry Features AccessibleUtilitiesOrLaundry MainLevel
Total Bedrooms 4
Main Level Bedrooms 4
Main Level Bathrooms 3
Total Baths 3
See more
GeneralSewer HoldingTank
Heating Gas ForcedAir
Utilities ElectricityConnected
Possession Closing
Roof Metal
Appliances Dryer Dishwasher ExhaustFan ElectricOven ElectricRange GasWaterHeater Refrigerator RangeHood Washer
Garage Spaces 0.0
Patio/Porch Features Open Porch
Architectural Style Contemporary HistoricAntique Transitional
Construction Materials BlownInInsulation Frame VinylSiding
School District Chautauqua Lake
Year Built 1858
Township Not Applicable
Property Subtype SingleFamilyResidence
Accessibility AccessibleBedroom
County Chautauqua
Property Type Residential
Subdivision Name Holland Land Company's Su
Garage Y/N No
Total Rooms 6
Full Baths 2
Status Active
Directions Property is on route 394 near the Magnolia Motel
City North Harmony
Senior Community Y/N No
High School District Chautauqua Lake
Number Of Units Total 0
MLS Area North Harmony-065400
Lot Size Units Acres
Lot Size Square Feet 15525.0
Year Built Details Existing
Tax Annual Amount 6088.0
Property Condition Resale
Virtual Tour https://youtu.be/l-sT8BQ_j3s https://youtu.be/oo2l_hc3kMc
Standard Status Active
Middle/Junior School District Chautauqua Lake
Elementary School District Chautauqua Lake
Tax Assessed Value 246800
TaxOtherAnnualAssessmentAmount 0.0
Tax Lot 29
See more
ExteriorExterior Amenities GravelDriveway
Parking Features NoGarage Driveway
Lot Features IrregularLot Other SeeRemarks
Water Source Well
Lot Size Area 0.3564
Foundation Details Block Stone
Building Area Total 2224.0
Lot Dimensions 115X135
Lot Size Acres 0.3564
Waterfront Y/N No
See more
* Excluded FeaturesList ByEra Team Vp Real EstateBroker
Affordability Calculator
- Monthly Principal & Interest
- $2,398
- Monthly Property Taxes
- $507
- Monthly Home Insurance
- --
Default based on a 30-year fixed rate of 6.25% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA or jumbo loans.
Learn more about how to save NearbySingle family listings in Mayville, NY
Average List Price $389,500
Percent of Sale Price 0%
About Mayville, NY 3,563 Population
-6% Since 2002
$ 53,083 Median Income
44.8 Median Age
20% Households with Children
Trends Information provided by ATTOM Data Solutions.
3323588 Elementary School
3323305 Middle School
Unknown High School High School
Pricing History| Date | Price | Price Change | Description |
|---|
| 6/3/2026 | $389,500 | -2.56% | Price Down |
| 12/12/2025 | $399,750 | | Listed Price |