2011 Oronico Drive

West Islip has something extraordinary on the market—2.25 acres of pure possibility. This kind of land, privacy, and flexibility is almost unheard of on Long Island. Wide-open grounds and endless sky create a private sanctuary just minutes from everything that makes this area so desirable. You’re close to the best of Babylon Village and Bay Shore, with their destination Main Streets, top restaurants, boutique shops, and vibrant year-round community life. And when it’s time for the beach, the award-winning shores by way of the nearby Robert Moses bridge and the Ferrys to Fire Island are only minutes away. The home offers expanded and dormered Cape Cod charm with five bedrooms, two full baths, and a massive high-ceiling basement ready to be transformed. An oversized front covered porch, a huge, covered breezeway leads to a walk-out lower level, giving the next owner even more room to imagine, expand, or reconfigure. Outside, the estate’s potential becomes undeniable. The in-ground pool needs attention—but that’s exactly where the opportunity lies. Revive it and instantly elevate the property into a personal resort. Patios, decks, mature landscaping, and a full sprinkler system surround the space. A gated section large enough for work trucks, RVs, or boats adds a level of utility rarely found in residential properties. A detached two-car garage with a finished, heated studio above—complete with cathedral ceilings—offers endless possibilities: creative studio, gym, guest cottage, or in-law suite. This is more than a listing. It’s a rare chance to own land, privacy, and potential in the award-winning West Islip School District. Properties like this don’t wait around.