1869 N Sr 257 Otwell, IN $ 390,000
1869 N Sr 257
$ 390,000
Recently Listed
Share Save

1869 N Sr 257

Otwell, IN, 47564
$ 390,000
Baths2.10 Sq 42,079

Monthly Estimate*

$ 2,463

1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 1
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 2
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 3
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 4
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 5
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 6
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 7
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 8
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 9
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 10
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 11
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 12
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 13
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 14
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 15
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 16
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 17
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 18
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 19
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 20
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 21
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 22
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 23
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 24
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 25
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 26
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 27
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 28
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 29
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 30
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 31
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 32
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 33
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 34
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 35
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 36
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 37
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 38
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 39
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 40
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 41
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 42
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 43
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 44
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 45
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 46
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 47
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 48
1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN 47564 - Image 49
View a Virtual Tour
Studio

Multi-Family Home for sale in Otwell, IN

for $390,000 with 2 full baths, 10 half baths. This 42,079 square foot home was built in 1973.

Located at 1869 N SR 257 in Otwell, Pike County, Indiana, this former Otwell Elementary School building is offered for sale on +/-10.79 acres. It is a rare renovation opportunity: +/-42,079 square feet under roof, built in 1973 with a 2001 addition featuring two-sided access, offered with complete building plans for the entire structure, included in the sale! The floor plan offers room for reinvention. Sixteen classrooms arranged in a rectangular layout provide a buyer with a wide range of flexible space to reconfigure, alongside a front office, library, kitchen, and stage. The combined gym and cafeteria is approximately 8,000 square feet of open, high-ceilinged space. Absent area zoning, the building holds potential to be redeveloped to fit your needs! Whether it be apartment residential housing, office space, an assisted living home, or a company's new headquarters and assembly facility! Multiple entrances and blacktop parking front and rear support a range of new uses, from multi-tenant to single-user. The building is all-slab construction with 10 total bathrooms throughout: one in the kitchen, one in the front office, one in each of two kindergarten classrooms, two in the teacher workroom, one in the nurse's office, and another by the center auditorium. The girls' and boys' locker rooms are both connected to the gym, which also has showers. Mechanically, the building includes 3 boilers believed to work, 2 chiller units, and 4 air handlers, existing infrastructure that a renovation can build on. Per the seller, one AC unit has a bad main computer, and the other has a hole in its tank, both of which are repairable. The kitchen walk-in cooler has worked before, but needs recharging. An elevator lift to the cafeteria stage and the fire alarm system are both believed to work. WIN Energy supplies power to the main building from the west, while the sign near SR 257 is powered separately by Dubois REC. Otwell Sewer & Water also services the building. The basketball and tennis courts await renovation. Otwell is a small Pike County community with an abundance of daily commuter traffic. Jasper is +/-10 miles away, Petersburg is +/-11 miles away, Washington is +/-17 miles away, and Evansville is +/-58 miles away, placing the property within reach of larger regional amenities and employment centers. Sold as-is, with complete building plans provided, this large-footprint building is ready for a buyer with vision to give it new life.

See more

Multi-Family Active

Price

$ 390,000

Bedrooms

Studio

Full Bath

2

Half Bath

10

Property Type

Multi-Family

Taxes

$ 0

Style

Year Built

1973

Town/City

Otwell

County/Region

Pike

MLS | Web ID

202635486

Features
General
Heating Other Heating Fuel
Cooling Other
Sewer Public
Status Active Active
Full Baths 2
Half Baths 10
Bathrooms 12
Year Built 1973
Parking Paved
New Construction No
Tenant Pays Other
Subdivision None
Style Other
Stories Count 1
Township Jefferson
Class INVESTMENT
Type Other
Age 53
Net Income -30222
Rent Income 0
Features Storage Court-Basketball Court-Tennis
REO No
Status Detail 0
Area Pike County
High School Pike Central
City Otwell
School District Pike County School Corp.
Total Sq Ft 42079
Elementary School Petersburg
Middle School Pike Central
Legal Description 002 01006 00 Pt Ne Ne 8 1 S 6 17.01 A 002 01005 00 Pt Ne Ne 8 1 S 6 .55 A 63-08-08-100-016.000-002 -- 002 01004 00 Pt Ne Ne 8 1 S 6 1.10 A
Virtual Tour https://www.propertypanorama.com/instaview/irmls/202635486
Agent First Name Briar
Agent Last Name Meadors
DOM 1
Tax Year 0
See more
Interior
Basement Other
Flooring Other
Beds 16
Total Number of Units 16
Microwaves 0
Refrigerators 0
Washers 0
Dryer(s) 0
Dishwasher(s) 0
Disposal(s) 0
Above Grade Bedrooms 16
Below Grade Baths 0
Below Grade Bedrooms 0
Total Rooms Below Grade 0
Ranges/Ovens 0
W/D Hookups 0
See more
Exterior
Exterior Brick
Pool No
Number of Parking Spaces 91
Lot Size Area 470012
Lot Dimensions irregular
Lot Description Irregular 10-14.999
Outbuilding None
Waterfront Y/N No
See more
* Excluded Features
List By
Briar Meadors

Listing Agent

Whitetail Properties Real Estate

Broker

briar.meadors@whitetailproperties.com

Email

Affordability Calculator

$2,463
Per Month
100%
0%
0%
Monthly Principal & Interest
$2,463
Monthly Property Taxes
--
Monthly Home Insurance
--
Default based on a 30-year fixed rate of 6.49% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA or jumbo loans.
Learn more about how to save

Discover how much house you can afford

Your dream home may be within reach.

Learn More about how to save

The time to sell is now
THE TIME TO SELL IS NOW! What's my home worth?
Nearby
1236746 Elementary School
1235601 Middle School
Pike Central High School High School
Pricing History
DatePricePrice ChangeDescription
8/28/2026$390,000 Listed Price

Map


See all

1869 N Sr 257, Otwell, IN, 47564 is a Multi-Family Home for sale at $390,000 with 42,079 sqft. 1869 N Sr 257 is a studio with 2.10 baths and was built in 1973. The property's zip code is 47564 which is in Otwell, IN