44 total properties
Did you mean the neighborhood Middle Island?
View 11 Eric Drive Middle Island, NY MLS# 1056731
$429,000
2

Beds

2.0

Baths

1,440

Sq.Ft.

11 Eric Drive

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS LEGENDARY
View 764 Birchwood Park Drive Middle Island, NY MLS# 1051486
$399,900
2

Beds

2.0

Baths

1,436

Sq.Ft.

764 Birchwood Park Drive

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of HOWARD HANNA COACH
View 196 Fairview Circle Middle Island, NY MLS# 1054746
$339,900
2

Beds

1.1

Baths

947

Sq.Ft.

196 Fairview Circle

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of HOWARD HANNA COACH
The time to sell is now! THE TIME TO SELL IS NOW!
View 273 Fairview Circle Middle Island, NY MLS# 1050968
$299,000
2

Beds

1.1

Baths

947

Sq.Ft.

273 Fairview Circle

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of BH&G R E REALTY CONNECT
View 717 Spring Lake Drive Middle Island, NY MLS# 1048181
$449,990
2

Beds

2.0

Baths

1,568

Sq.Ft.

717 Spring Lake Drive

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER AMERICAN HOMES
View 78 Artist Lake Drive Middle Island, NY MLS# 1043276
$300,000
2

Beds

2.0

Baths

1,098

Sq.Ft.

78 Artist Lake Drive

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of OVERSOUTH LLC
View 69 Fairview Circle Middle Island, NY MLS# 1043431
$364,990
2

Beds

2.0

Baths

1,086

Sq.Ft.

69 Fairview Circle

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER AMERICAN HOMES
View 203 Lake Pointe Circle 203 Middle Island, NY MLS# 1041416
$239,000
2

Beds

1.0

Baths

860

Sq.Ft.

203 Lake Pointe Circle 203

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of KERRIGAN COUNTRY REALTY
View 874 Birchwood Park Drive Middle Island, NY MLS# 1037323
$389,900
2

Beds

1.0

Baths

1,100

Sq.Ft.

874 Birchwood Park Drive

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER AMERICAN HOMES
View 282 Fairview Circle Middle Island, NY MLS# 1037955
$355,000
2

Beds

1.1

Baths

947

Sq.Ft.

282 Fairview Circle

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE
View 349 Artist Lake Drive Middle Island, NY MLS# 1036361
$299,000
2

Beds

1.1

Baths

947

Sq.Ft.

349 Artist Lake Drive

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of EXIT REALTY ALL PRO
View 244 Lake Pointe Circle #244 Middle Island, NY MLS# 1025350
$269,000
2

Beds

1.0

Baths

999

Sq.Ft.

244 Lake Pointe Circle #244

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER AMERICAN HOMES
View 190 Lake Pointe Circle 190 Middle Island, NY MLS# 983086
$285,000
2

Beds

1.0

Baths

930

Sq.Ft.

190 Lake Pointe Circle 190

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY
View 178 Fairview Circle Middle Island, NY MLS# 1021419
$325,000
2

Beds

2.0

Baths

947

Sq.Ft.

178 Fairview Circle

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of SERHANT EAST END LLC
View 58 Bailey Court 58 Middle Island, NY MLS# 1023449
$189,900
1

Beds

1.0

Baths

775

Sq.Ft.

58 Bailey Court 58

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of HOWARD HANNA COACH
View 124 Fairview Circle Middle Island, NY MLS# 1016345
$285,000
2

Beds

1.1

Baths

947

Sq.Ft.

124 Fairview Circle

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of SIGNATURE PREMIER PROPERTIES
View 515 Picasso Way 515 Middle Island, NY MLS# 1012247
$329,000
2

Beds

1.0

Baths

901

Sq.Ft.

515 Picasso Way 515

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of SUNRISE PREMIER R E LLC
View 28 Bailey Court 28 Middle Island, NY MLS# 994831
$179,000
1

Beds

1.0

Baths

700

Sq.Ft.

28 Bailey Court 28

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of REALTY CONNECT USA L I INC
View 50 Gauguin Court 50 Middle Island, NY MLS# 991106
$269,990
2

Beds

1.0

Baths

900

Sq.Ft.

50 Gauguin Court 50

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of H & G REALTY NEW YORK
View 71 Crystal Rock Court Middle Island, NY MLS# 991165
$445,000
3

Beds

2.0

Baths

1,332

Sq.Ft.

71 Crystal Rock Court

Middle Island, NY

Courtesy of RE/MAX INTEGRITY LEADERS

About Middle Island

The relaxed community of Middle Island seems to preserve the caring and gentle attitude that was first symbolized by its 19th century Light Station. Located in the "middle" of Long Island, the town has been built up over the decades with homes, coop apartments, condominiums, churches, small businesses, and commercial development. The Prosser Cathedral Pines area located on the road to Yaphank is distinguished as the largest white pine forest on Long Island. The oldest trees date back to 1812, and this beautiful preserve is now open to the public as part of Suffolk County Parks. In addition to good schools and the local library, one of the highlights of the community is the Middle Island Country Club. The accepting, casual nature of Middle Island is reflected in the friendly spirit of the club, which tends to be a favorite of residents and visitors alike.

Listings in Middle Island, NY

97

Estimated median home price

$479,000
Middle Island NY Homes for Sale & Properties

Weichert Realtors is one of the nation's leading providers of Middle Island, New York real estate for sale and home ownership services. Contact Weichert today to buy or sell real estate in Middle Island, NY.

Homes for Sale by Price in Middle Island, NY

PriceCount
$0 - 100K0
$100K - 200K3
$200K - 300K22
$300K - 400K12
$400K - 500K21
$500K - 600K16
$600K - 700K14
$700K - 800K2
$800K - 900K5
$900K - 1M1
$1M - Max1

Homes for Sale by Type in Middle Island, NY

Property TypeCount
Single Family39
Townhouse0
Condo37
Commercial1
Rental18
Lots and Land4
Condo/Town/CoOp0
CoOp16
Multi Family0
Mobile Home0
Farms0

(Data as of 11/17/2026)

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of OneKey® MLS.

The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use.

Information Copyright 2021, OneKey® MLS. All Rights Reserved.