View 54 Charles Place Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26008483
  • Recently Listed
Save 54 Charles Place Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26008483
1 of 32
$1,495,000
4

Beds

4.1

Baths

54 Charles Place

Old Tappan, NJ

NewJerseyMLS
Courtesy of NEW WORLD PROPERTIES
View 99 Ogle Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26005280
  • Recently Listed
Save 99 Ogle Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26005280
1 of 43
$2,579,000
6

Beds

5.1

Baths

99 Ogle Road

Old Tappan, NJ

NewJerseyMLS
Courtesy of SERHANT NEW JERSEY LLC
View 7 Orchard Lane Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26006902
  • Recently Listed
Save 7 Orchard Lane Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26006902
1 of 20
OPEN HOUSE: Sunday 3/29 12:00 PM - 3:00 PM
$2,890,000
5

Beds

6.1

Baths

7 Orchard Lane

Old Tappan, NJ

NewJerseyMLS
Courtesy of SERHANT NEW JERSEY LLC
The time to sell is now! THE TIME TO SELL IS NOW!
View 1 Sherwood Court Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26007264
    Save 1 Sherwood Court Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26007264
    1 of 41
    $1,699,000
    5

    Beds

    4.1

    Baths

    1 Sherwood Court

    Old Tappan, NJ

    NewJerseyMLS
    Courtesy of SERHANT NEW JERSEY LLC
    View 468 Old Tappan Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26005949
      Save 468 Old Tappan Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26005949
      1 of 44
      $699,900
      4

      Beds

      2.1

      Baths

      468 Old Tappan Road

      Old Tappan, NJ

      NewJerseyMLS
      Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS VALLEY REALTY
      View 5 Lakeview Drive Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26005493
        Save 5 Lakeview Drive Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26005493
        1 of 28
        $975,000
        3

        Beds

        2.2

        Baths

        5 Lakeview Drive

        Old Tappan, NJ

        NewJerseyMLS
        Courtesy of RE/MAX NOW - NORWOOD
        View 1011 Washington Avenue Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26004706
          Save 1011 Washington Avenue Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26004706
          1 of 35
          OPEN HOUSE: Saturday 3/28 12:00 PM - 3:00 PM
          $1,299,000
          3

          Beds

          2.1

          Baths

          1011 Washington Avenue

          Old Tappan, NJ

          NewJerseyMLS
          Courtesy of SERHANT NEW JERSEY LLC
          View 40 Orangeburgh Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26002410
            Save 40 Orangeburgh Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26002410
            1 of 30
            $739,000
            3

            Beds

            1.1

            Baths

            40 Orangeburgh Road

            Old Tappan, NJ

            NewJerseyMLS
            Courtesy of CORCORAN INFINITY PROPERTIES, RIVER VALE
            View 2 Stewart Court Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26002690
              Save 2 Stewart Court Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26002690
              1 of 49
              $2,950,000
              5

              Beds

              6.1

              Baths

              2 Stewart Court

              Old Tappan, NJ

              NewJerseyMLS
              Courtesy of SERHANT NEW JERSEY LLC
              View 31 Leonard Drive Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25042890
                Save 31 Leonard Drive Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25042890
                1 of 16
                $1,200,000
                Studio

                Beds

                0.0

                Baths

                31 Leonard Drive

                Old Tappan, NJ

                NewJerseyMLS
                Courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER, HILLSDALE
                View 31 Leonard Drive Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25042895
                  Save 31 Leonard Drive Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25042895
                  1 of 13
                  $1,200,000
                  4

                  Beds

                  2.0

                  Baths

                  31 Leonard Drive

                  Old Tappan, NJ

                  NewJerseyMLS
                  Courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER, HILLSDALE
                  View 231 Birchwood Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26001114
                  • Virtual Tour
                  Save 231 Birchwood Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 26001114
                  1 of 42
                  $1,499,000
                  4

                  Beds

                  2.1

                  Baths

                  231 Birchwood Road

                  Old Tappan, NJ

                  NewJerseyMLS
                  Courtesy of SERHANT NEW JERSEY LLC
                  View 215 White Avenue Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25041714
                  • Virtual Tour
                  Save 215 White Avenue Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25041714
                  1 of 42
                  $1,395,000
                  4

                  Beds

                  2.1

                  Baths

                  215 White Avenue

                  Old Tappan, NJ

                  NewJerseyMLS
                  Courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER, ALLENDALE/SADDLE RIVER VALLEY
                  View 112 Winding Creek Way Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25038701
                    Save 112 Winding Creek Way Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25038701
                    1 of 49
                    $959,000
                    3

                    Beds

                    3.1

                    Baths

                    112 Winding Creek Way

                    Old Tappan, NJ

                    NewJerseyMLS
                    Courtesy of C LAND REALTY CO.
                    View 27 Pine Hill Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25040916
                      Save 27 Pine Hill Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25040916
                      1 of 50
                      $2,425,000
                      6

                      Beds

                      4.1

                      Baths

                      27 Pine Hill Road

                      Old Tappan, NJ

                      NewJerseyMLS
                      Courtesy of SERHANT NEW JERSEY LLC
                      View 192 White Avenue Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25040164
                        Save 192 White Avenue Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25040164
                        1 of 48
                        $1,899,999
                        4

                        Beds

                        3.2

                        Baths

                        192 White Avenue

                        Old Tappan, NJ

                        NewJerseyMLS
                        Courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER, ALPINE/CLOSTER
                        View 7 & 11 Stokes Farm Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25038705
                          Save 7 & 11 Stokes Farm Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25038705
                          1 of 40
                          $5,888,711
                          6

                          Beds

                          6.2

                          Baths

                          7 & 11 Stokes Farm Road

                          Old Tappan, NJ

                          NewJerseyMLS
                          Courtesy of SERHANT NEW JERSEY LLC
                          View 32 Moeser Place Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25012688
                            Save 32 Moeser Place Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25012688
                            1 of 50
                            $2,199,000
                            6

                            Beds

                            5.2

                            Baths

                            32 Moeser Place

                            Old Tappan, NJ

                            NewJerseyMLS
                            Courtesy of SERHANT NEW JERSEY LLC
                            View 43 Old Tappan Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25035856
                              Save 43 Old Tappan Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25035856
                              1 of 19
                              $1,395,000
                              4

                              Beds

                              2.0

                              Baths

                              43 Old Tappan Road

                              Old Tappan, NJ

                              NewJerseyMLS
                              Courtesy of MCSPIRIT & BECKETT REAL ESTATE
                              View 1 Woods Edge Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25025123
                                Save 1 Woods Edge Road Old Tappan, NJ MLS# 25025123
                                1 of 41
                                $1,399,000
                                4

                                Beds

                                4.1

                                Baths

                                1 Woods Edge Road

                                Old Tappan, NJ

                                NewJerseyMLS
                                Courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER, RIDGEWOOD

                                About Old Tappan

                                Old Tappan with its beautiful private golf course provides an intimate and predominantly residential atmosphere.  Proximity to regional malls, first-rate schools, and excellent commuter transportation add to the quality of life.  Commuters have access to the Garden State Parkway and New Jersey Turnpike as well as commuter bus service to New York City.

                                Listings in Old Tappan, NJ

                                21

                                Estimated median home price

                                $1,399,000
                                Old Tappan NJ Homes for Sale & Properties

                                Weichert Realtors is one of the nation's leading providers of Old Tappan, New Jersey real estate for sale and home ownership services. Contact Weichert today to buy or sell real estate in Old Tappan, NJ.

                                Homes for Sale by Price in Old Tappan, NJ

                                PriceCount
                                $0 - 100K0
                                $100K - 200K0
                                $200K - 300K0
                                $300K - 400K0
                                $400K - 500K0
                                $500K - 600K0
                                $600K - 700K1
                                $700K - 800K1
                                $800K - 900K0
                                $900K - 1M2
                                $1M - Max17

                                Homes for Sale by Type in Old Tappan, NJ

                                Property TypeCount
                                Single Family17
                                Townhouse3
                                Condo0
                                Commercial0
                                Rental16
                                Lots and Land1
                                Condo/Town/CoOp0
                                CoOp0
                                Multi Family0
                                Mobile Home0
                                Farms0

                                (Data as of 3/24/2026)

                                Browse Neighborhoods

                                Find Properties in Old Tappan, NJ

                                Old Tappan, NJ Information

                                Find Properties by Zip

                                Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

                                The data relating to the real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange Program of the NJMLS. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Weichert Realtors are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. Some properties listed with the participating brokers do not appear on this website at the request of the seller. Listings of brokers that do not participate in Internet Data Exchange do not appear on this website.

                                All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Last date updated: 3/26/2026.

                                Source: New Jersey Multiple Listing Service, Inc.

                                © 2026 New Jersey Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.