623 W Milroy Avenue
Rensselaer, IN, 47978 $ 549,500
Bedrooms6 Baths3.1 Sq 3,771 Monthly Estimate*
$ 3,383
for $549,500 with 6 bedrooms and 3 full baths, 1 half bath. This 3,771 square foot home was built in 1893 on a lot size of 0.6.
Welcome to one of the most admired Victorian homes on Milroy Ave. rich in history, unforgettable charm, and thoughtfully updated for the way we live today. Built in 1893, this 3-story treasure offers approximately 3,770 SF of distinctive character on just over 1/2 acre, framed by mature trees and a beautiful black metal fence. Step onto the wide front porch and look up the porch ceiling is painted haint blue, an old Southern tradition believed to protect the home and welcome good energy. Inside, you'll find exquisite architectural details at every turn: Two sets of original pocket doors, Inlaid hardwood floors in many rooms, Sun-filled spaces thanks to abundant natural light, Intricate trim and original craftsmanship rarely seen today. The main floor offers exceptional flow for everyday living and entertaining, featuring: A formal living room, parlor, and library, A spacious dining room for gatherings, A bright kitchen and adjoining breakfast area surrounded by windows and a window seat, plus a cozy family room. There are 6 Bedrooms, one on each of the 3 floors, arranged to allow privacy and comfort, along with multiple bathrooms to accommodate family and guests. The highlight of the 2nd Story is the Gorgeous Sunroom. The outdoor spaces are wonderful. Enjoy a large deck with swimming pool, Firepit for evening gatherings, Play fort and the Original Victorian pond, a rare feature that connects you back to the home's history. The basement houses the Laundry, Utility Area and tons of storage. Low Taxes and close proximity to downtown and parks. The geothermal heating/cooling are a wonderful upgrade, and the roof was put on in October of 2025. This home has been the backdrop to countless holidays, celebrations, and story-filled evenings. Now, it's ready for its next chapter and for someone who appreciates beauty, craftsmanship, and the charm only a historic home can offer. See if you can find in the photos where the owners paid homage to some original wallpaper!
See more
FeaturesGeneralSewer Public
Heating Geothermal
Kitchen Level Main
Cooling Central Air
Laundry Y/N Basement
Fireplaces Yes
Garage Attached
Amenities Breakfast Bar Closet(s) Walk-in Countertops-Laminate Deck Open Firepit Foyer Entry Garage Door Opener Porch Covered Stand Up Shower Tub/Shower Combination Formal Dining Room
Status Active Active
Full Baths 3
Half Baths 1
Bathrooms 4
Year Built 1893
New Construction No
Subdivision None
Style Two Story
Township Marion
Class RESIDENTIAL
Type Site-Built Home
Age 133
REO No
Status Detail 0
Common Amenities None
Dining Room Level Main
Area Jasper County
Location City/Town/Suburb
High School Rensselaer Central
City Rensselaer
School District Rensselaer Central School Corp.
Architectural Style Victorian
Total Sq Ft 5128
Elementary School Rensselaer Central
Middle School Rensselaer Central
Legal Description N 191.8' W PT OL 5 EXC W 35' SW NW 30 29 6 .60A
Virtual Tour https://www.propertypanorama.com/instaview/irmls/202609014
Agent First Name Terri
Agent Last Name Phegley
DOM 1
Tax Year 2024
See more
InteriorBasement Partial Basement
Fireplace(s) 3
Flooring Hardwood Floors Carpet Laminate
HVAC Energy Star Heating
Beds 6
Total Rooms 15
Dining Room Length 22
Dining Room Width 11
Breakfast Room Length 19
Breakfast Room Width 14
Fireplace Family Rm Living/Great Rm 4th Bdrm
Family Room Width 13
Living Room Width 13
Other Room 1 Description Parlor
Other Room 2 Description Sun Room
Other Room 3 Decription 2nd floor landing
Family Room Length 13
Living Room Length 17
Full Baths Main 1
Full Baths Upper 2
Above Grade Bedrooms 6
Below Grade Baths 0
Below Grade Bedrooms 0
Full Baths Below Grade 0
Half Baths Below Grade 0
Half Baths Main 1
Half Baths Upper 0
1st Bedroom Level Upper
1st Bedroom Width 18
2nd Bedroom Length 13
2nd Bedroom Level Main
2nd Bedroom Width 13
3rd Bedroom Length 13
3rd Bedroom Level Upper
3rd Bedroom Width 13
4th Bedroom Length 15
4th Bedroom Level Upper
4th Bedroom Width 13
5th Bedroom Length 14
5th Bedroom Level Upper
5th Bedroom Width 12
Extra Room Description Bedroom #6
Extra Room Length 12
Extra Room Level Upper
Extra Room Width 10
Basement Material Stone
See more
ExteriorExterior Aluminum Wood
Driveway Concrete
Pool Yes
Pool Type Above Ground
Garage Length 18
Garage Width 23
Lot Size Area 26136
Lot Dimensions 125 x 200
Lot Description Level 0-2.9999
Fence Other-See Remarks
Garage Capacity 2
Waterfront Y/N No
See more
* Excluded FeaturesList ByTerri PhegleyListing Agent
Cornerstone Real Estate AgencyBroker
tphegley@cornerstoneshomes.comEmail
Affordability Calculator
- Monthly Principal & Interest
- $3,383
- Monthly Property Taxes
- $152
- Monthly Home Insurance
- --
Default based on a 30-year fixed rate of 6.25% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA or jumbo loans.
Learn more about how to save NearbySingle family listings in Rensselaer, IN
Average List Price $349,000
Percent of Sale Price 36%
About Rensselaer, IN 5,684 Population
3% Since 2002
$ 46,164 Median Income
37.15 Median Age
32% Households with Children
Trends Information provided by ATTOM Data Solutions.
5167071 Elementary School
5167070 Middle School
Rensselaer Central High School High School
Pricing History| Date | Price | Price Change | Description |
|---|
| 3/19/2026 | $549,500 | | Listed Price |