638 S Main Street

Built in 1872 by Arthur Potter Richter (1844-1928), the Richter House stands as a remarkable piece of Madison's architectural and cultural history preserving its historic character. From its wrap-around front porch, to its full-length windows, the charm of an old house is hard to recreate. In 2018, the current owners further elevated the property with the addition of a screened-in porch, pool, and pool house, seamlessly blending 19th-century craftsmanship with modern luxury. Inside, the home retains its original heart pine floors and antique wavy-glass windows, details that immediately speak to its authenticity and age. The floor plan balances gracious entertaining spaces with comfortable daily living. A generous dining room and expansive great room create natural gathering places, while the light-filled kitchen features quartz countertops, custom cabinetry, and stainless appliances that complement the home's historic charm. With 4 bedrooms, each with its own full bath, this home is perfect for a family or a house full of guests. The vaulted family room with built-in bookcases opens effortlessly onto the screened-in porch, creating an easy indoor-outdoor flow that overlooks the beautifully landscaped backyard. Upstairs, the oversized primary suite offers a serene retreat complete with a soaking tub, modern tiled shower, walk-in closet, and a bright nook ideal for reading or quiet workspace. The well-designed laundry room provides flexibility for additional storage, office use, or even a small fitness area. Throughout the home, professionally curated lighting and custom window treatments enhance the thoughtful design. The outdoor living spaces transform the property into a private resort. The fully fenced yard features a heated saltwater pool and spa, fire pit, and a beautifully appointed pool house complete with an open-air kitchen, vaulted den area, bar, half bath, and changing room. All pool house, pool and patio furniture is included in the sale. Whether hosting intimate evenings or larger gatherings, the property accommodates entertaining with ease. Arthur was one of eight children of Charles William Richter, a German silversmith, and Anna Eliza Potter Richter, who emigrated from St. Croix and settled in Madison prior to Arthur's birth. He was raised just blocks away in the Richter Cottage, circa 1836, on West Washington Street. The Richter family played an active role in Madison's early commercial life, operating several businesses including a photography studio in the historic Richter Building, now home to the Coldwell Banker office at 168 South Main Street. Arthur's brother, Martin Luther Richter, owned the well-known Dovecote House on South Main Street. When Arthur purchased this one-acre parcel in 1871 for $500, it was considered the outskirts of town. There he and his wife, Frances Cornelia Fielding Richter, established a family home that would remain in Richter hands for three generations. His grandson, Charles Woodruff "Woody" Richter, Jr., became a beloved Madison figure as the town's longtime mail carrier. The property ultimately left the family in 1994, after which a series of thoughtful renovations enhanced the home's livability while preserving its historic character. In 2018, the current owners further elevated the property with the addition of a screened-in porch, pool, and pool house, seamlessly blending 19th-century craftsmanship with modern luxury. This is a rare opportunity to own a historically significant residence in Madison's esteemed Historic District-where preserved heritage, architectural integrity, and modern comfort coexist in perfect harmony.