11 Pine St

Set in the heart of America’s oldest city, this remarkable 1890 two-story property offers a rare blend of history, land and potential. Situated on a large corner lot, the property enjoys exceptional views toward the shoreline marked by the cross where Ponce de León is believed to have come ashore, placing it among a small handful of homes connected so directly to the city’s earliest history. Its classic proportions and enduring structure speak to craftsmanship from another era, and the large lot offers a sense of privacy rare in the heart of the city. The two-story main house retains historic charm, offering a canvas for restoration and modernization. High ceilings, tall windows and generous porches reflect the architectural sensibilities of the period. While the home is currently livable, it requires updating and rehabilitation, presenting an exceptional opportunity to restore and reimagine a unique piece of St. Augustine history. The layout allows for flexibility, whether you want to preserve traditional room separations or open spaces for a more modern flow. Natural light filters in and the upper-level captures elevated views and breezes. With thoughtful design, this residence could seamlessly blend historic integrity with contemporary comfort. Currently, the home includes a small efficiency-style in-law suite downstairs, which could be transformed into a charming private retreat, maintaining separation while remaining connected to the main home. A large garage workshop anchors the rear of the property, offering space for storage, restoration projects, or creative pursuits. This structure is valuable for those who appreciate functional space in an urban historic setting; perhaps for a woodworking shop, art studio or storage. There is also a separate small cottage, ideal for a kid's play house, small office, studio or retreat. Detached from the main residence, these buldings provides privacy and flexibility, especially appealing for remote work/creative endeavors. The large lot and proximity to downtown truly distinguishes this property. The expansive grounds provide room to breathe, garden, create, and expand possibilities. It offers compelling walkability. From the front door, it’s an easy stroll to downtown St. Augustine and its renowned historic sites — the Castillo de San Marcos, Matanzas Bay, St. George Street, museums, galleries, shops, cafés, and restaurants. This home is more than a residence; it is a restoration opportunity steeped in legacy. With vision and care, it can become stunning. The premier location makes it truly exceptional. For those who value history, character, and potential, who seek a property that tells a story while inviting a new one, this St. Augustine home stands ready for its next chapter.