1424 Main Street

Step into a rare opportunity to own one of Sylvan Beach’s most beloved and established landmarks — Captain John’s Restaurant & Shipwreck Bar, a family-owned and operated business thriving for over 50 years. This turn-key property is ideally suited for an owner-operator or savvy investor seeking a proven, profitable enterprise in the heart of one of Central New York’s most visited waterfront villages. The property includes a fully equipped and meticulously maintained bar and restaurant, known for its loyal following and complete with strong financials. Above the restaurant are two well-kept residential apartments, offering additional income or on-site living. Sitting proudly on a large corner lot with ample parking and water views of Oneida Lake, the building is in exceptional condition inside and out. The versatile layout provides endless potential — continue the legacy of Captain John’s, bring your own restaurant or retail concept, or repurpose the structure and property entirely for a new vision. Prime Location Highlights: - Located right on the hustle and bustle of Main St! - Just one block from Sylvan Beach’s public beach access. - Tourists and visitors flock to Sylvan Beach each year, drawn by its waterfront charm, entertainment, and family attractions. - Minutes from premier regional destinations including: The Cove at Sylvan Beach (Oneida Nation’s luxury cottage and marina development), The Lake House at Sylvan Beach (casino, dining, and event venue), Sylvan Beach Amusement Park, Turning Stone Resort & Casino (~15 minutes), Griffiss Business & Technology Park / Airforce Base (~20 minutes), City of Utica (~25 minutes), Proposed Site of the NEW Chobani Dairy Processing Facility (~20 minutes), Gateway to the Adirondacks for year-round recreation, This property combines the best of both worlds — a proven, profitable business and exceptional real estate value in one of Central New York’s fastest-growing leisure markets. Whether you are looking to carry on a half-century legacy or create something entirely new, 1424 Main Street offers unmatched potential in an unbeatable location.