Open House 12/20 1pm - 3pm
86 Garfield Street
Lancaster, NY, 14086 $ 349,900
Bedrooms3 Baths2.0 Sq 1,689 Monthly Estimate*
$ 2,183
for $349,900 with 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths. This 1,689 square foot home was built in 1927 on a lot size of 0.399.
Discover this move-in ready 3 bedroom, 2 full bath home perfectly situated on a spacious double corner lot, offering room to spread out both inside and out. With a brand new roof and newer windows throughout, peace of mind comes built in. Step inside to an inviting open floor plan that blends style and functionality. The kitchen is the heart of the home, featuring a large center island ideal for casual dining, entertaining, or family gatherings. The spiral staircase adds a striking architectural detail, leading to a private upstairs primary suite designed as your own retreat. Convenience meets practicality with first-floor laundry and a full basement for additional storage or hobby space. The property’s true standout is the detached 2-story garage, offering endless opportunities — create your dream workshop, a man cave, guest or in-law suite, or even finish it as an apartment for additional living space or rental income. This hidden gem offers the perfect balance of charm, updates, and versatility. With its generous lot, unique design features, and endless potential, this home is ready to welcome its next owners to enjoy, create, and make it their own. Square footage difference of 755 sq. ft., bringing it to a total of 1,689 sq. ft., was updated by an appraiser (see letter in attachments).
See more
Open House
12/20/2025 1:00 PM - 3:00 PM
86 Garfield Street Lancaster, NY
* Some states or local ordinances may prohibit Open Houses at this time, please confirm with your Weichert agent or local rep to confirm
FeaturesInteriorInterior Amenities Den SeparateFormalDiningRoom EatInKitchen SeparateFormalLivingRoom KitchenIsland MainLevelPrimary
Basement Full
Flooring Carpet Hardwood Varies Vinyl
Total Fireplaces 0
Total Stories 1
Basement (Y/N) Yes
Air Conditioning Y/N Yes
Heating Y/N Yes
Fireplace Y/N No
Half Baths 0
Laundry Features MainLevel
Total Bedrooms 3
Main Level Bedrooms 2
Main Level Bathrooms 1
Total Baths 2
See more
GeneralSewer Connected
Heating Gas ForcedAir
Cooling CentralAir
Utilities CableAvailable SewerConnected WaterConnected
Possession CloseOfEscrow
Appliances Dishwasher GasOven GasRange GasWaterHeater Microwave Refrigerator
Garage Spaces 3.0
Architectural Style Colonial TwoStory
Construction Materials VinylSiding
School District Lancaster
Year Built 1927
Electric CircuitBreakers
Stories Count 1
Township Lancaster-Village
Levels One
Property Subtype SingleFamilyResidence
Accessibility Other
County Erie
Property Type Residential
Attached Garage No
Subdivision Name Diamond Sub
Garage Y/N Yes
Total Rooms 6
Full Baths 2
Status Active
Directions Norris Ave to Garfield St. or your favorite GPS.
City Lancaster
Senior Community Y/N No
High School District Lancaster
Number Of Units Total 0
MLS Area Lancaster-Village-145203
Lot Size Units Acres
Lot Size Square Feet 17380.0
Year Built Details Existing
Tax Annual Amount 4840.0
Property Condition Resale
Standard Status Active
Middle/Junior School District Lancaster
Elementary School District Lancaster
Tax Assessed Value 142000
TaxOtherAnnualAssessmentAmount 0.0
Tax Lot 1
See more
ExteriorExterior Amenities ConcreteDriveway EnclosedPorch Fence Porch
Fencing Partial
Parking Features Detached Garage
Lot Features Rectangular RectangularLot ResidentialLot
Water Source Connected Public
Lot Size Area 0.399
Foundation Details Poured
Building Area Total 1689.0
Lot Dimensions 110X158
Lot Size Acres 0.399
Waterfront Y/N No
Road Frontage Type CityStreet
See more
* Excluded FeaturesList ByHoward Hanna Wny Inc.Broker
Affordability Calculator
- Monthly Principal & Interest
- $2,183
- Monthly Property Taxes
- $403
- Monthly Home Insurance
- --
Default based on a 30-year fixed rate of 6.375% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA or jumbo loans.
Learn more about how to save NearbySingle family listings in Lancaster, NY
Average List Price $376,919
Percent of Sale Price 8%
About Lancaster, NY 44,738 Population
15% Since 2002
$ 69,422 Median Income
43.78 Median Age
28% Households with Children
Trends Information provided by ATTOM Data Solutions.
246444 Elementary School
246634 Middle School
Unknown High School High School
Pricing History| Date | Price | Price Change | Description |
|---|
| 10/22/2025 | $349,900 | -10.26% | Price Down |
| 10/11/2025 | $389,900 | -2.53% | Price Down |
| 9/23/2025 | $400,000 | | Listed Price |