118 Pomar St

Excellent Potential in the Heart of Historic Lincolnville! Nestled on a peaceful street in beloved Lincolnville—a neighborhood on the National Register of Historic Places—this charming 1920s two unit home offers the perfect blend of historic character, modern flexibility, and unbeatable location. Surrounded by historic homes, ancient oaks, and welcoming porches, this is true Old Florida living—with serious income potential. Directly next door to the Lincolnville Museum and Cultural Center, this two-unit property is a rare find. The ground floor features a beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 1-bath vacation rental, while the upstairs hosts a cozy studio apartment with a full kitchen, currently leased to a long-term tenant. Whether you're looking to rent both units, live in one and lease the other, or maybe convert it to a full-time residence, the options here are endless. Running street-to-street, the lot offers ample parking—a major bonus for guests and tenants alike, or room for expansion. And when it comes to location, you simply can't beat it. Just a short walk or bike ride away, you'll discover some of St. Augustine's best restaurants and local gems—including the St. Augustine Distillery, Ice Plant, Fish Camp, La Nouvelle, and the Corner Market. Need to cool off? Head to the sparkling Galimore Pool, open to the public and perfect for sunny afternoons. Downtown’s historic sites, waterfront, and vibrant arts scene are easily accessible by foot, bike, or trolley, which stops right next door at the Museum. Whether you're seeking a savvy investment, a charming residence with rental income, or a combination of both, this Lincolnville home delivers. Second floor photos are from previous short term rental use. First floor is currently a short term rental.