1174 Potter Mountain Road Gilboa, NY ^$ 3,400,000

1174 Potter Mountain Road

^$ 3,400,000

Back to search

1174 Potter Mountain Road

Gilboa, NY, 12076

^$ 3,400,000

Bedrooms5 Baths4.1 Sq 6,242

Monthly Estimate*

^$ 21,212

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 1

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 2

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 3

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 4

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 5

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 6

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 7

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 8

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 9

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 10

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 11

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 12

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 13

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 14

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 15

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 16

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 17

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 18

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 19

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 20

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 21

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 22

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 23

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 24

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 25

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 26

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 27

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 28

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 29

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 30

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 31

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 32

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 33

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 34

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 35

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 36

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 37

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 38

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 39

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 40

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 41

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 42

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 43

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 44

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 45

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 46

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 47

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 48

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 49

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 50

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 51

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 52

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 53

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 54

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 55

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 56

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 57

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 58

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 59

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 60

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 61

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 62

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 63

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 64

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 65

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 66

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 67

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 68

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076 - Image 69

View a Virtual Tour

Single Family Home for sale in Gilboa, NY

for $3,400,000 with 5 bedrooms and 4 full baths, 1 half bath. This 6,242 square foot home was built in 1837 on a lot size of 37.

Introducing Potter Mountain House, a masterfully reimagined 1837 Greek Revival church transformed into a luxury designer estate on 37 acres with Catskill views. Redesigned by ICDT Studio in 2023, it blends original timber framing and soaring windows with refined contemporary details. Highlights include a Great Room with a sculptural gas fireplace, chef's kitchen with high-end appliances, a dramatic library loft in the original cupola, wine room, five bedrooms, four-and-a-half baths, and a finished walkout lower level. Outdoors, terraces, a stream, and panoramic views complete the setting. Offered with a furnished turnkey option and ideally located just minutes from Windham Mountain—yet within reach of NYC and other upstate destinations—Potter Mountain House is truly one of a kind.

Single Family Active

Price

^$ 3,400,000

Bedrooms

Full Bath

Half Bath

Property Type

Single Family

Taxes

^$ 8,180

Style

Greek Revival

Lot Size

Year Built

1837

Town/City

Gilboa

County/Region

Schoharie

MLS | Web ID

202519417

Features

Interior

Interior Amenities High Speed Internet Walk-In Closet(s) Wet Bar Cathedral Ceiling(s) Eat-in Kitchen Kitchen Island Built-in Features

Basement None

Flooring Tile Wood Hardwood

Total Fireplaces 1

Fireplace Features Gas Living Room

Basement (Y/N) N

Air Conditioning Y/N Y

Heating Y/N Y

Window Features Double Pane Windows

Fireplace Y/N Y

Above Grade Finished Area 6242.0

Half Baths 1

Laundry Features Laundry Room

Total Bedrooms 5

Below Grade Finished Area 0.0

Below Grade Finished Area Source Plans

Above Grade Finished Area Source Plans

Total Baths 5

Kitchen Island True

General

Sewer Other

Heating Forced Air Heat Pump Propane Radiant Floor

Cooling Other Central Air

Utilities Cable Connected

Possession At Closing

Roof Metal

Appliances Ice Maker Dishwasher Dryer Freezer Microwave Range Range Hood Refrigerator Tankless Water Heater Washer Wine Cooler

Garage Spaces 2.0

Patio/Porch Features Deck Patio

Architectural Style Greek Revival

Construction Materials Other Clapboard Stone Wood Siding

Year Built 1837

Electric Underground 200+ Amp Service Circuit Breakers

View Meadow Mountain(s) Trees/Woods

Property Subtype Single Family Residence

County Schoharie

New Construction N

Property Type Residential

HOA N

Attached Garage Y

Garage Y/N Y

Total Rooms 18

Full Baths 4

Status Active

Directions Take NY-145 turn left on Potter Hollow Rd road name will change to Potter Mountain Rd property is on the left.

City Gilboa

High School District Gilboa-Conesville

Lot Size Units Acres

Lot Size Square Feet 1611720.0

Carport Y/N N

Land Lease Y/N N

Tax Annual Amount 8180.23

Home Warranty Y/N N

Property Condition Updated/Remodeled

Lease Renewal Y/N N

Additional Parcels Y/N N

Lease Considered Y/N N

Rent Control Y/N N

Virtual Tour https://www.zillow.com/view-imx/20e66395-ed9c-4d91-bf9a-f36d4fb6a266/?utm_source=captureapp

Standard Status Active

Tax Assessed Value 0

Exterior

Exterior Amenities Drive-Paved Garden Lighting

Parking Features Paved Attached Driveway Garage Door Opener Heated Garage

Lot Features Meadow Mountain(s) Private Sloped Views Wooded Garden

Total Parking 2.0

Lot Size Area 37.0

Foundation Details Concrete Perimeter Slab Stone

Spa N

Lot Size Acres 37.0

Waterfront Y/N N

Crops Included Y/N N

Horse Y/N N

Irrigation Water Rights Y/N N

Internal Only

Street Number 1 1174

* Excluded Features

List By

Anthony D'Argenzio

Listing Agent

Houlihan Lawrence

Broker

(518) 821-0826

Phone

adargenzio@houlihanlawrence.com

Affordability Calculator

$21,893

Per Month

Monthly Principal & Interest: $21,212
Monthly Property Taxes: $682
Monthly Home Insurance: --

Set your offer price

Down Payment

Loan Term

Interest Rate

Yearly Property Taxes

Yearly Home Insurance

Default based on a 30-year fixed rate of 6.375% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA or jumbo loans.

Learn more about how to save

Discover how much house you can afford

Your dream home may be within reach.

Learn More about how to save

THE TIME TO SELL IS NOW! What's my home worth?

Nearby

Trends
Schools

Single family listings in Gilboa, NY

Average List Price ^$756,085

Percent of Sale Price 78%

About Gilboa, NY

1,322 Population

8% Since 2002

^$69,018 Median Income

51.79 Median Age

23% Households with Children

View more area information

Trends Information provided by ATTOM Data Solutions.

2479687 Elementary School

2479685 Middle School

Unknown High School High School

See complete school information

Pricing History

Date	Price	Price Change	Description
10/7/2025	$3,400,000	-12.71%	Price Down
6/12/2025	$3,895,000		Listed Price

Map

More homes like this one

homes for you

See all

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY, 12076 is a Single Family Home for sale at $3,400,000 with 6,242 sqft and a lot size of 37. 1174 Potter Mountain Road has 5 bedrooms, 4.1 baths, and was built in 1837. The property's zip code is 12076 which is in Gilboa, NY

*Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Financial calculator disclaimer: Default based on a 30-year fixed rate of 6.375% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA or jumbo loans.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from The Internet Data Exchange Program of ©2019 Global Multiple Listing Service, Inc. The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the GMLS. All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties subject to prior sale, change, or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s), GMLS shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, or misprints, and shall be held totally harmless from any damages arising from reliance upon these data. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties they may be interested in purchasing.

Data is updated as of 12/19/2025.

*Full Name

*Email

*Phone

I am interested in financing options

Get more info

By submitting the form, you agree that Weichert^® may contact you via phone or text about your inquiry, which may involve the use of automated means. You are not required to consent as a condition of purchasing any property, goods or services. For any other information please read our privacy policy.

Get more info

Looking for an Associate?

Already Working with an Associate?

1174 Potter Mountain Road

Single Family Home for sale in Gilboa, NY

Affordability Calculator

Map

More homes like this one

Get more info about this home