37 Main Street Hurley, NY 12443

37 Main Street, Hurley, NY 12443

Single Family Home for sale in Hurley, NY

for $350,000 with 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths. This 3,636 square foot home was built in 1700 on a lot size of 1.4.

Property Information

  • $350,000
  • 3 Bedrooms
  • 2 Full Baths
  • Single Family
  • 3,636 Square Feet
  • Taxes are $9,785
  • Colonial
  • Active
  • Lot size of 1.4
  • Built in 1700
  • Hurley, NY
  • Ulster County
  • MLS/Web ID is 20181574

 Virtual Tour


The Spy House, also known as the DuMond House or the Guard House, was built some time between about 1680 and about 1720. It may be the oldest continuously occupied private residence in New York State. It was built by the DuMond/VanEtten family, and in the 1930s was purchased by the Kent family. It was serving as the local militia company's guardhouse when a British soldier captured as a spy was held here for several days before being hanged from an apple tree across the street. The house has been expanded several times over the centuries, so some of the interior walls were originally exterior ones. Some of the windows and doors are believed to be original. The property is on Town water (from Kent Springs) and has a septic system. Because of its history as the village post office, it also has a few parking spaces.There are very few supporting interior walls, so the space is very flexible. Rooms have been added and reconfigured often over the centuries. People are often surprised at how much larger the house is once inside, compared to how small it appears from the street. The post office addition, 700 square feet on the ground floor with a standup attic, was erected in the early 1950s. It became the village post office in 1953 and served until 1986. Under Hurley's zoning rules governing the historic district, a special use permit could be issued so that this space could be used for professional offices, an artist's studio, or a B&B, but not as a retail shop. The second floor, of about 1, 000 square feet, has been partitioned over the years into several rooms of various sizes: One large master bedroom two small bedrooms with an open space between; a small room that has been used as a nursery and playroom; and a large bathroom, as well as a number of closets and storage areas. The bricks in the chimney were made in nearby Rosendale; there were formerly many brickworks in this region. There is a small attic above this floor accessible by the stepladder on the ceiling near the attic door. 1.4+/- arces this amazing home sits on in the heart of Hurley. Come take a look. 3 bedroom 2 full baths with 3636 sq ft. 3 beatuiful fireplaces grace this beauty on the Main St in Hurley.

Room Information

  • Bedroom (11.5x11.5)
  • Bedroom (11.8x11.3)
  • Bedroom (7.3x11)
  • Dining Room (14.2x19.5)
  • Kitchen (Eat-In) (16.2x19.11)
  • Living Room (15.6x19.5)
  • Office
  • Utility Room

Interior 10


  • Dryer
  • Range
  • Refrigerator
  • Washer


  • Storage Only
  • Walk-up Attic

Building Amenities

  • Garden


  • Fireplace in Dining Room
  • Fireplace in Kitchen
  • Fireplace in Living Room
  • Stone

Heating Source

  • Oil

Heating System

  • Forced Air
  • Hot Water Heater: Solar


  • Beamed Ceilings

Room Features

  • Country Kitchen
  • Eat-in Kitchen


  • Septic System

Water Source

  • Community Water

Exterior 8


  • Stone


  • Blacktop
  • Driveway


  • Barn
  • Enclosed Patio/Porch
  • Landscaped
  • Storage / Out Building / Shed


  • Barn Garage

Lot Description

  • Level/Flat


  • Off Street Parking


  • Asphalt Shingles


  • Stone Exterior
  • Wood Exterior

† Excluded Feature

Neighborhood & Schools

School District: Kingston Consolidated

 See complete school information

Listed By

Listing Agent: Jeanne Boice

37 Main Street, Hurley, NY, 12443 is a Single Family Home for sale at $350,000 with 3,636 sqft and a lot size of 1.4. 37 Main Street has 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, and was built in 1700. The property's zip code is 12443 which is in Hurley, NY

Get an Immediate Callback from 9:00 AM - 10:30 PM EST
or Call us at 1-800-839-1363

Pricing History

Date Price Price Change Description
9/24/2018 $350,000 -6.67 % Price Change
6/29/2018 $375,000 -6.23 % Price Change
5/4/2018 $399,900 Listed Price

Market Pricing

Average % of sale price Median % of sale price
All listings in Hurley $521,169 49 % above $295,750 16 % below
Single family listings in Hurley $496,725 42 % above $299,000 15 % below

Get the facts about Hurley, NY!

Population 6,295
Population Growth (since 2000) -4 %
Median Income $65,366
Median Age 50.76
Households w/ Children 20 %

Residential Dwellings

  • Owned 2318
  • Vacant 328
  • Rented 370

Similar Listings

Get an Immediate Callback from 9:00 AM - 10:30 PM EST
or Call us at 1-800-839-1363