734 Old Post Road New Paltz, NY 12561

734 Old Post Road, New Paltz, NY 12561
Call 1-800-839-1363

Single Family Home for sale in New Paltz, NY

for $995,000 with 4 bedrooms and 5 full baths. This 4,404 square foot home was built in 1895 on a lot size of 14.3 Acre(s).

Property Information

  • $995,000
  • 4 Bedrooms
  • 5 Full Baths
  • Single Family
  • 4,404 Square Feet
  • Taxes are $9,904
  • Colonial
  • Active
  • Lot size of 14.3 Acre(s)
  • Built in 1895
  • New Paltz, NY
  • Ulster County
  • MLS/Web ID is 20171457


The former Grace Line Estate, a classic center-hall colonial, was built in 1895, with two identical wings added in the 1930s to create a rambling and elegant home the likes of which are rarely found west of the Hudson. Perched high on a hill with seasonal mountain views, this stately home is surrounded by over 14 acres of magical forest and dramatic rock outcrops. While beautiful wood floors, interior and exterior details and the workmanship of an earlier time are evident throughout the house, new infrastructure has been sensitively put in place without compromising integrity. The gracious floor plan includes many public and private spaces of varying proportions, ideal for large groups or more intimate gatherings. The well-appointed kitchen opens to the rear patio for outdoor dining in warmer months, and to the spacious formal dining room, where large numbers of guests are easily accommodated. Three wood-burning fireplaces add loads of atmosphere – one in the capacious family room, one in the library, and one in the living room, a space adorned with the most beautiful moldings. There’s also a 3-room suite on the first floor with a stunning bathroom with a steam shower, which would make for a private in-law or guest space. Up on the second floor there are bedrooms and bathrooms for a crowd, all light and bright, including an ensuite master, a Jack-and-Jill set up, and space for a nanny too, at the top of the back staircase. The finished walk up attic, with its own full bathroom, makes for an ideal playroom, office, workout space or studio. An enormous dry basement adds plenty of storage space to a house that already has lots of closets. The beautiful grounds lend themselves to quiet walks in the woods, game playing, gardening and, by night, stargazing. There’s plenty of room to add a pool or tennis court as well. The central location makes access to the city easy, whether by train from Poughkeepsie, bus from New Paltz, or a ride down the Thruway. Nearby towns and attractions are plentiful, including Kingston, High Falls/Stone Ridge, The Culinary Institute, Fisher Center at Bard College, Smorgasburg, farmers markets and local points of interest galore.

Room Information

  • Attic (10x31)
  • Bedroom (11.6x17)
  • Bedroom (11.6x17)
  • Bedroom (11.7x12.2)
  • Bedroom (12.2x16.9)
  • Den (11.9x16.7)
  • Dining Room (12.3x24.3)
  • Family Room (12.2x25.6)
  • Kitchen (15x17)
  • Living Room (19.6x22)
  • Other (11.3x15.10)
  • Other (8.8x11.2)

Interior 10


  • Carbon Monoxide Detector
  • Dishwasher
  • Dryer
  • Oven (Built-in)
  • Range
  • Refrigerator
  • Smoke Detector
  • Washer


  • Attic
  • Walk-up Attic

Cooling System

  • Central Air


  • Brick
  • Fireplace in Family Room
  • Fireplace in Living Room

Heating Source

  • Oil

Heating System

  • Forced Air
  • Oil Hot Water


  • Sauna

Room Features

  • Breakfast Bar
  • Cabinets - Custom Built
  • Cabinets - Wood
  • Master Bath


  • Septic System

Water Source

  • Well

Exterior 6


  • Frame


  • Insulated Windows
  • Patio
  • Storage / Out Building / Shed


  • 2 Car

Lot Description

  • Meadow
  • Rocky
  • Wooded / Trees


  • Asphalt Shingles


  • Shake Shingle

Miscellaneous 2


  • Rural


  • Cable Internet Available

† Excluded Feature

Neighborhood & Schools

School District: New Paltz Schools

 See complete school information

Listed By

Listing Agent: Jeff Serouya

734 Old Post Road, New Paltz, NY, 12561 is a Single Family Home for sale at $995,000 with 4,404 sqft and a lot size of 14.3 Acre(s). 734 Old Post Road has 4 bedrooms, 5 baths, and was built in 1895. The property's zip code is 12561 which is in New Paltz, NY

Get More Info – Our Customer Service Center will contact you between 9:00 AM - 10:30 PM EST

Market Pricing

Average % of sale price Median % of sale price
All listings in New Paltz $545,229 45 % below $429,500 57 % below
Single family listings in New Paltz $594,984 40 % below $549,900 45 % below

Get the facts about New Paltz, NY!

Population 13,955
Population Growth (since 2000) 9 %
Median Income $66,790
Median Age 26.83
Households w/ Children 21 %

Residential Dwellings

  • Owned 2567
  • Vacant 319
  • Rented 1940

Similar Listings

Get More Info – Our Customer Service Center will contact you between 9:00 AM - 10:30 PM EST